List of alleged season 2 competitors

This page describes the list of characters that will debut in the instance that a second season of Battle for Fish is made. While it is not yet confirmed whether a second season will be created yet, the characters have already been created.

The list is ordered in chronological order, by when they were officially added.

Peripheral Nervous Systemy
Peripheral Nervous Systemy (nicknamed Nervey or simply PNSy) is a character originally created by Yamburger. Implied by his name, he is a chart that details a human being's peripheral nervous system.

Manny
Manny is an image of an unknown person with legs. His asset features an upper-body image of a person in a suit with their arms crossed, with their eyebrows and mouth erased. His mouth and eyebrows are animated, but strangely, the eyes remain still. Although their debut may never happen at all, they are the first character to be given a voice by a different voice actor.

This Dog
This Dog is a cropped, blurry image of a dog. It has no animated features.

Abomination
Abomination is a melted snow sculpture of Tennis Ball and Golf Ball from Battle for Dream Island. It is a pile of snow with several sticks in it.

Attempty
Attempty is a poorly drawn yellow star. Their face is a text box.

Roblox Head
Out of all the other characters who were recommended for BFF Season 2, Roblox Head is the most different compared to their original recommendation. They were originally one of the faces of the game, but in the final product, ended up being a full head. She is a cylinder with a face that does not move.

Illegal Bag
Referred to as simply "Bag," Illegal Bag is a large plastic bag containing an unspecified substance (implied in their original recommendation to be cocaine). Bag has retractable arms, unlike any other contestants.One character was originally recommended for BFF 2, but was scrapped. They were a large hot air balloon piloted by a small skeleton, called "Balloony BFDI." They were cut from the cast for several reasons. A second character without a recommender, Bladey, was cut as well.

Season 2, should it enter development, will be hosted by Sam the Salmon, a (living) relative of Fish's.